Evangelical discomfort with prosperity

Keep the change, son.
"Keep the change, son".

Evangelical Christians are okay with God’s spiritual blessings but are ill at ease with material blessing from God.

One reason is an over-reaction to the excesses of the “prosperity gospel”.  We look with disdain on some American television evangelists who raise millions from naive believers by twisting Scriptures to say what they do not say, to support grandiose projects, and flaunt a lavish lifestyle that Solomon would envy.

The PEST test

An easy way to check for “prosperity doctrine” quotient is to do a PEST test that I have developed:

P –  Presumption is “an assumption, often not fully established, that is taken for granted in some piece of reasoning.” “Prosperity doctrine” is built on assumptions that are not fully borne out by the whole counsel of God, and their tenets are flawed by tenuous interpretation of scripture passages.

E – Eternity: “Prosperity doctrine” have no regard for what is eternal, accusing others of “pie in the sky” irrelevancy.  Jesus told us not to accumulate wealth on earth but to lay our treasures in heaven. He had a high regard with living on earth with a view to eternity. Hold to our material wealth lightly and be contented and free from greed and hoarding.

S – Stewardship: “Prosperity doctrine” does not emphasize God’s ownership of all things and how discipleship entails the faithful and wise management of God’s resources and places all our resources at God’s disposal. Jesus said, “You cannot serve God and Money(Matthew 6:24).” This practically means the wealthy Christian should use his wealth to honor God, and care for the poor and needy, this good old earth and world missions.

T – Thanksgiving: “Prosperity doctrine” does not cultivate humility and gratitude and generosity. It has tendencies toward materialism, and unchecked consumption and pride. “Give me neither poverty nor riches, but give me only my daily bread. Otherwise, I may have too much and disown you and say, “Who is the Lord?” (Proverbs 30:8,9)

So we rightly say no to “prosperity doctrine” but sadly are hesitant to preach about God’s desire to bless us so that we can bless others. We do not want to be associated with “prosperity doctrine” and so we stay in the safety of the boat and do not risk teaching rightly what the Word says about God’s fatherly desire to bless his children.

God wants to bless

I preach that God wants to bless his children. He blessed Adam and Eve, Noah, Abraham and many may have missed this scripture: “When He had led them out to the vicinity of Bethany, he lifted up his hands and blessed them. While he was blessing them, he left them and was taken up into heaven.”( Luke 24:39). It seems to me that every significant new beginning, was launched with the blessing of God, unmerited and free, and that blessing included material benefits as well as spiritual. He wants us to “put our hope in God who richly provides us with everything for our enjoyment”(1 Timothy 6:17).

In the Old Testament, as in Abraham’s case, the blessing of God covered his family, finances, protection, guidance and did not exclude the spiritual for by faith righteousness was credited to his account, and he sought a city not made by hands. The promises of blessing to those who fully obey in Deuteronomy 28:1-14 would easily have had Abraham as an example of fulfillment.

Evangelical dis-ease must be cured

Evangelical Christians think that the New Testament blessings emphasizes spiritual blessings but not to the exclusion of the temporal and material.  I rejoice and thank God for all the spiritual blessings secured for us through Christ’s death and resurrection. However, the reluctance and neglect of preaching about how God loves to bless us with “daily bread”, a temporal and material blessing embedded in the Lord’s prayer itself, does a disservice to the church. Our heavenly Father is mistakenly regarded as one reluctant to bless us with material resources as well as spiritual. Paul declared boldly that God wants “to make all grace abound toward you so that you, always having all sufficiency in all things, may have an abundance for every good work”(2 Corinthians 9:8).

This evangelical dis-ease must be cured.

Let’s not junk the good with the part that’s spoiled.

Share this:


  • i have developed a test too.

    1) the key is to PAINT a different christ. this christ must wear branded clothings and employs personal accountant to justify your claim to prosperity
    2) preach EASY grace to target guilt ridden souls. do you know of anyone who does no wrong in life? the more sensitive the soul, the more generous he/she is.
    3) capture your audience with SUPERNATURAL Promises. never mind you can’t prove it so long as you can fire someone’s imagination.
    4) link TITHING to love and offerings/blessings. there is no greater love than sacrificial love. how can you shut your wallet to someone who died for you?

    so P.E.S.T = Paint your way to Easy Supernatural Tithing = prosperity

    • Hey Friend,
      are u for real?
      linking easy grace?what is easy? and supernatural tithing to prosperity?
      i don’t know u….yet.But don work too much on ur own assumptions….makes an ass out of u n me( and everyone else).


  • wow, i have 2 Corinthians 9:8 pinned up on my office desk, thanks for reminding 🙂

    yes i agree with you. God wants to bless us in all areas of our live including material blessings. This is not wrong, but we need to have the wisdom to understand that by blessing us with money/possessions, it’s to allow us to have the resources to bless others, not to be using them as a means to glorify our own success. Money should never become something of greater importance than God. When we learn to part with money, we gain the spirit of generosity and kindness and God will bless us even more abundantly. The principle of tithing that always sticks into my head is this “if you can;t even part with 10% of your income, how can God entrust you with the 100 or 1000-fold blessings that He’s waiting to give you”?

  • Christianity has become a dualism of wanting denial and an eternal struggle(or justification) between trying to be a mother teresa who gets down and dirty with slumdogs or a benny hinn bestowed with “out of reach of most decent working class folks” mansion and a pte jet to chapter one from the toilet to the finest kopitiam in town.

  • Hi Kenny, your blogpost is sound, reasonable and biblical. Thanks for your insight. If you don’t mind, I will use your “Pest” test in my sermon this Sunday.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *